Skip to content
SouthernTree & Roofing
Menu

Guide

Remove a tree or trim it?

A practical way to decide between tree removal and trimming in a Memphis yard, including roof clearance, topping, stumps, and power lines.

Published by Southern Tree & Roofing on . 4 minute read.

Memphis yards are full of trees that are bigger than the lot plan imagined. The decision is usually not "big tree, take it down." It is whether the tree is sound, and whether the problem is a limb or the whole stem. Southern Tree & Roofing does both tree removal and tree trimming. This is how we talk about the choice. It is not a claim that every large tree is dangerous, and it is not a claim that every limb over a roof has to go.

Trim when the structure is still good

Trimming is the right conversation when the trunk and the main branch unions are sound and you are solving a specific problem:

  • Deadwood hanging over a roof, a walk, or a driveway
  • A live limb rubbing shingles or packed into a gutter
  • A long limb that a storm can use as a lever, which can be shortened back to a lateral branch
  • Clearance for a roof repair or for light into a room, without hollowing out the canopy

A few feet of gap between foliage and the roof is a practical target so the next season of growth does not put the limb back on the shingles. The exact cut depends on the species and the shape. The cut should land at a lateral branch that can take over, not in the middle of a bare stub.

A widely used written benchmark for this kind of pruning is the ANSI A300 tree-care standard. You can ask any crew whether their cuts follow that idea. This site does not claim a certification.

Oaks, pines, sweetgums, and magnolias are all common in Memphis yards, and they do not want the same cuts. Say what the tree is if you know it. A photo of the whole tree from the yard, plus a closer photo of the limb you worry about, is enough to start.

Remove when the tree cannot be made safe with pruning

Talk about removal when one of these is true:

  • The tree is dead
  • The trunk is split, or so hollow that the shell is what is holding it up
  • The root plate has lifted and the tree is leaning toward a house, a car, or a neighbor
  • The tree has already failed and is on a structure, which is emergency storm tree removal
  • Pruning enough wood to make it safe would leave something that is no longer a tree

A lean that has been there for years, with sound roots and no recent change, is not the same as a lean that appeared after a wind and a week of rain. Tell us whether the lean is new.

Size is not on that list. A large, sound shade tree over an East Memphis or Midtown roof is often a tree to keep, with clearance pruning, because the shade is also what keeps the roof from baking quite so hard. Removing it is a permanent choice.

Do not buy topping as if it were a trim

Topping means cutting the crown off and leaving large stubs, sometimes sold as "taking a third off" or "reducing it so it will not fall." The sprouts that come back are weakly attached. The stubs decay. In a few years the tree is more hazardous than when you started, and usually uglier.

If a price is far lower because the work is topping, it is not a bargain. Ask for pruning to a lateral. If the tree cannot be made safe that way, the honest option is removal, not a haircut.

The roof underneath

Limbs that sand shingles wear the granules off in a stripe. That stripe can be a roof repair after the limb is cleared, or it can be one more reason a worn-out roof needs replacement. Look at the shingles from the ground or from an upstairs window. A polished or bald streak under the canopy is abrasion. Random dark soft spots after a hail day are a different pattern, described in signs you need a roof replacement after a Memphis storm.

You can hire the tree work without the roof work. Say which one you want when you call.

Power lines, nests, and the stump

If any part of the tree is on a power line, stop. In Shelby County, call MLGW (opens in a new tab). In Southaven, the city lists Entergy for electricity, not MLGW. A tree crew does not cut a limb off a live line.

If the tree holds an active bird nest, timing can change. Federal law protects many native migratory birds and their active nests. The U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service explains the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (opens in a new tab). We are not a wildlife survey. If we see a nest in use, we will pause and talk about it rather than pretend it is not there.

Removal does not include the stump unless the quote says so. Stump grinding puts the stump below mowing grade. It does not excavate the whole root system. Call 811 (opens in a new tab) before grinding so public utilities can be marked. Private lines you buried yourself may not be on that ticket.

Historic districts in Midtown, and HOAs in places such as Germantown and Collierville, sometimes have their own rules about removal. Check those before you schedule. We do not claim to file that paperwork unless the quote says we will.

A simple way to call it

Send the address, a photo of the whole tree, and a sentence about what changed: "limb on the roof," "new lean after Saturday's wind," "dead since last summer." Call (901) 728-8065 weekdays from 9:00 am to 5:00 pm. If the tree is on the house or a line is down, use the storm order of operations above before you worry about whether the long-term choice is a trim or a removal.

Sources

Free estimate

Memphis and Nashville. Free estimate. We reply during weekday hours.

Call (901) 728-8065
  • Free estimates. Hiring us is optional.
  • Insurance claim help means photos and a written scope. Your insurer decides the claim.
  • Locally owned shop at 939 Kelley Rd in Memphis. Nashville is a service area, not a second address.
  • We answer Mon-Fri 9:00 am-5:00 pm and return storm calls when we can. Arrival time is not guaranteed.

Request a quote · (901) 728-8065

Call now